Can the Mariners End Their Curse and Claim the MLB Title This Year?

As the 2025 baseball postseason kicks off, the air is thick with anticipation and a dash of heartbreak. Some teams, despite their flaws or misfortunes, will be glaringly absent, leaving a void only their passionate fans can truly feel. Take the Pirates, for example—though their season stumbled repeatedly, Paul Skenes’s jaw-dropping fastballs and baffling late-breaking pitches kept us glued to our screens, questioning what’s physically possible on a mound. And then there’s the end of an era with the Astros, whose nine-year playoff streak and multiple titles crafted a dynasty that, love ‘em or hate ‘em, made October all the more intoxicating. Meanwhile, the Orioles’ young talent and hopeful supporters endured a tough 2025, reminding us just how electric Camden Yards can be when alive with cheers and dreams.

But the drama doesn’t stop there. High seeds like the Brewers, who dazzled all summer, face a treacherous path ahead—will a prolonged postseason pause disrupt their rhythm and dash their championship hopes? And the Tigers, squeezed by a surging Guardians team capitalizing on a historic Detroit implosion, find themselves in precarious territory as the playoffs heat up.

Yet, lurking in the shadows are formidable dark horses—the Padres with their lethal bullpen or the Mariners, still chasing that elusive first World Series, fueled by fresh stars and October veterans alike. Even the revitalized Red Sox, rounding back into form with a balanced attack and seasoned players, have us wondering if they might just steal the show.

As we dissect pivotal factors like bullpen strength and mega-contract debates, it’s clear the stakes couldn’t be higher. With seasoned veterans, rising phenoms, and seismic shifts on the horizon, this postseason promises stories that will resonate for years. Who will rise? Who will fall? One thing’s sure: baseball’s magic never fades.

LEARN MORE

Team that that will be most missed from the playoffs

The Pirates may have been abysmal again but have remained appointment viewing thanks to Paul Skenes, whose highlight reels make you question physics. It’s not just his raw pace, throwing 100mph+ deep into games, but his mastery of late-moving variations that mean batters can’t pick whether it’s a sweeper or a splinker until it’s already behind them. Alan Evans

The Astros. They’d made the playoffs for nine straight years, winning a couple of World Series, four American League pennants and seven AL West titles. Sure, they were villains on merit, but gravity-defying dynasties like Houston’s only make for richer postseason narratives. Bryan Armen Graham

Well, these days, it’s hard to miss any team because just under half of them make the playoffs. That said, the Orioles have great young talent and a fanbase starving for a winner. When Camden Yards is full and buzzing it’s one of the best atmospheres in North American sports. Their 2025 has to be considered one of the most disappointing seasons in recent memory, unless you’re a Mets fan of course. David Lengel

High seed at risk of going out early

The Brewers surged to the best record in baseball (96-65) with an astonishing summer after having been 25-28 on 24 May. But their momentum slowed in September, and with the new extended wildcard format giving the best teams a five-day break, that may be enough to knock them off their rhythm and send them home early. AE

The Brewers could be vulnerable. The NL Central champions have come back to earth after the 14-game win streak that vaulted them to the best record in baseball. There are questions over the fitness of closer Trevor Megill and they’ll have a tricky NLDS draw with the Padres or Cubs after a five-day layoff. BAG

That has to be the Tigers, who are facing a Guardians team that came out of nowhere to capitalize on a historic Detroit collapse. Cleveland’s recent stretch of allowing just 32 earned runs in 19 games was otherworldly, and it’s helped earn them three home games v Detroit. There’s only one Tarik Skubal pitching for the Tigers, so that means they’re in trouble. DL

Dark horse to win

The Padres are used to being overlooked in favor of their more glamorous neighbors in Los Angeles, but they have a dangerous core led by Manny Machado and Fernando Tatis Jr, and the bullpen’s 3.06 ERA is by far the best in baseball. If they can keep games close early on, they will be hard to shake off. AE

The Mariners are the lone major league team to have never reached a World Series much less won one. They have a strong chance of finally breaking that hoodoo thanks to the emergence of rookie sensation Cal Raleigh and proven October commodity Randy Arozarena. BAG

The Red Sox have come out of this dormant phase, won back their temporarily apathetic fan base and are quite good, and importantly, well-rounded. They do everything well, and despite the loss of rookie phenom Roman Anthony, probably have enough to oust the Yankees this round, and more. They have the ace in Garrett Crochet and two Comeback Player of the Year candidates in Trevor Story and Aroldis Chapman. Don’t be surprised if they pull of their fifth title of the century. DL

Most important factor this postseason/offseason

The Dodgers already have the best – and best-paid – lineup in baseball, but are still likely to give Kyle Tucker a megacontract this offseason. If that does happen, calls will grow for a long-overdue look at competitive balance and the rules about salary deferrals. This won’t stop the Dodgers winning 100+ games a year for the next decade, but it could shape the outcome of the collective bargaining agreement due after next season. AE

Bullpen upgrades. In today’s game, the difference between winning and losing in October often comes down to late-inning arms in high-leverage situations. Any team that can lock down seventh-to-ninth inning relief dominance will head into 2026 with a huge competitive edge. BAG

Well, so much of the pitching world surrounds bullpens these days, with starters having trouble going deep into games. LA’s relief core has struggled, but now that their starters are healthy, and the pen can breathe a little, the Dodgers are well placed to use their core more effectively. San Diego’s bullpen, with Mason Miller is terrifying. On the flip side, expect the Yankees bullpen to let them down at just the wrong time. DL

NLCS

Dodgers over Padres. AE

Phillies over Brewers. BAG

Dodgers over Brewers. DL

ALCS

Yankees over Mariners. AE

Mariners over Yankees. BAG

Mariners over Blue Jays. DL

Your World Series champions will be …

The Dodgers may be facing injury struggles, most notably catcher Will Smith’s fractured hand, but no team has a deeper roster. They have the best player in the world in Shohei Ohtani, an experienced batting lineup who know how to win in the postseason, and the potentially powerful storyline of retiring team hero Clayton Kershaw being used as a super-reliever if they make the World Series. His teammates would love to send him off with another championship, and they have the quality and consistency to dominate any opponent. AE

The Phillies boast one of the most balanced rosters in baseball, even without ace Zack Wheeler. Cristopher Sánchez, Ranger Suárez and Jesús Luzardo headline a rotation that can carry games deep, sparing a top-heavy bullpen. Jhoan Duran, electrifying in the ninth, has turned Citizens Bank Park into a theater of intimidation. Offensively, Kyle Schwarber and Bryce Harper – two of the generation’s best October sluggers – anchor a lineup bolstered by Rob Thomson’s platoons and a supporting cast with eight double-digit homer hitters. Harper feels destined for a World Series MVP run after 2022’s near-miss, while Schwarber (56 homers) has generally thrived under pressure. The X-factor? Trea Turner’s return from a hamstring injury. If he finds his rhythm, Philadelphia’s combination of power, depth, and home-field magic makes them the most compelling case to win it all in 2025. BAG

The Mariners were born in 1977 and have never won the big one. Nearly 50 years later, they’re ready to shock the Dodgers and finally bring that elusive title to the northwest corner. It won’t be a shock, because Seattle have the talent and they’re peaking at the right time. With should-be MVP Cal Raleigh, Julio Rodríguez and Randy Arozarena, their lineup is beefy. But it’s the pitching rotation, with depth from Bryan Woo, Luis Castillo and Logan Gilbert that’s found elite form over the last month, combining with a pen in top gear that make them so formidable. Yes, they really can match LA, and if they can somehow strikeout a little bit less, they’ll pip the Dodgers in seven. DL