Nationals Bet Big on Unknown Blake Butera: Can a Dugout Rookie Ignite a Team in Crisis?

It’s a curious thing, really—when Blake Butera first stepped into middle school hallways, the Washington Nationals were still nothing more than a gleam in someone’s eye, not yet a fixture in baseball’s sprawling landscape. Fast forward, and here we find ourselves at Nationals Park, where on a brisk Monday afternoon, this 33-year-old was unveiled as the eighth manager to steer the Nationals’ ship. Beneath the stadium’s surface, a room swelling with anticipation buzzed amidst a sea of red, white, and blue blooms, packed with faces both familiar and influential—from the Lerner family’s discreet front-row presence to an army of front-office staff in their uniform quarter-zips filing every corner. Up front, the scene was stark yet poignant: two placards announcing the arrival of Butera and Paul Toboni, the newly minted president of baseball operations. Toboni, only two years older and hailing from the Red Sox ranks, didn’t mince words; he championed Butera’s rare gift for connecting with all corners of the baseball world—a quality he touted as indispensable. With a red cap set just so and his fresh white uniform donned, Butera didn’t just look the part—he spoke with the calm conviction of a man who believes character will carve this team’s identity anew. It’s a tall order, no doubt—a rebuilding squad shadowed by some of baseball’s toughest seasons since their 2019 championship glimmer. Yet with youth, hope, and a fresh perspective now at the helm, the Nationals are betting on a future molded by genuine leadership, infectious unity, and bold ambition. This is more than a managerial hire; it’s the dawn of a new era in D.C. baseball—a leap of faith that already has fans wondering what’s next in this unfolding saga.

LEARN MORE

WASHINGTON — When new Washington Nationals manager Blake Butera entered middle school, the Washington Nationals did not yet exist.

His age, or lack thereof, was a main character at Nationals Park on Monday afternoon as the eighth skipper in franchise history was formally introduced. The stadium’s subterranean press conference room, adorned with red, white and blue roses, was packed to the gills for the occasion. Members of the club’s elusive ownership group, the Lerner family, peppered the front few rows. A large throng of front-office officials, clad in a department store’s worth of obligatory quarter-zips, crammed themselves into the back of the room.

Up on the podium sat just two placards; one for Butera and one for his new boss, Paul Toboni, the team’s recently hired president of baseball operations.

“As you’ve heard me say many times over the course of the last six weeks, I’m a strong believer that you win with people,” Toboni, 35, offered during his opening statement. “And Blake’s character and ability to connect with everyone across the baseball spectrum is second to none.”

The two men then shook hands before Butera, 33, curved a red cap onto his head and pulled a crisp white uniform over his 5-foot-9 frame. He and Toboni, formerly an assistant general manager for the Boston Red Sox, briefly posed for a few pictures before the skipper, still too young to run for president, settled in to introduce himself.

“As we move forward, our identity is going to start with character,” Butera proclaimed. “I believe true leadership is built on real relationships, relationships that create unity, clarity and a shared purpose.”

The job in front of him is daunting.

[Get more Nationals news: Washington team feed]

Since raising the World Series trophy in 2019, the Nationals have slogged to baseball’s second-worst record, better than only the catastrophically discombobulated Colorado Rockies. The trades conducted in the teardown of that core have borne some fruit, most notably the Juan Soto deal that brought young All-Star outfielder James Wood to D.C.

But in the main, Washington has been a draft-and-development disasterclass, an organization distinctly unskilled at making players better. That half-decade run of ineptitude reached a turning point this past July, when a pair of title-winning stalwarts, GM Mike Rizzo and manager Davey Martinez, were simultaneously fired.

And now, into that void, charge Toboni and Butera, a pair of unwrinkled, clean-shaven 30-somethings. Together, they come armed with fresh perspectives, cathedral expectations of themselves and almost zero big league experience. Butera, in fact, has never spent a day in a Major League dugout.

Drafted by the Tampa Bay Rays in the 35th round of the 2015 MLB Draft after a plucky four years at Boston College, the infielder’s playing career petered out after two minor league seasons. But Butera quickly and successfully made the transition to coaching. In 2018, still just 25 years old, he was named manager of Tampa’s short-season Hudson Valley affiliate. After two strong years there, Tampa pushed him to Low-A Charleston, where he won back-to-back league championships and a Manager of the Year award. That eventually earned him a big new gig as the Rays’ senior director of player development, a role that he served in until his hiring a few weeks ago. Butera was also the bench coach for Team Italy under manager Mike Piazza during the 2023 World Baseball Classic.

It’s an impressive résumé, but not necessarily one that would have pointed to a big league head job, at least not in such short order. In fact, Butera admitted that he entered this winter not expecting to be a part of the managerial carousel. His biggest concern was much closer to home: Butera’s wife Caroline was set to have the couple’s first child around the last week of October, right as the Nats were trying to finalize the hiring.

To simplify things, Toboni flew down to Raleigh, where the Buteras live, so that Blake could stay close to home just in case Caroline went into labor. It all came together on the same day, with Blake receiving the job offer before the birth of their newborn Blair and accepting it later that day after having become a father. It has been a whirlwind, to say the least.

But Butera, ever-youthful, did not appear worn down by the taxing, early days of parenthood. That is, by all accounts, par for the course. Despite being “young for the level” at every turn, the new skipper has thrived. Butera draws rave reviews for a special ability to communicate with players, empowering them to get the most out of their skills. In that sense, his lack of trips around the sun have proved helpful, allowing him to relate better to players close to him in age.

That will remain an important dynamic in D.C., as a young Nats roster attempts to author a pivot back to contention. A whopping 60 percent of the team’s plate appearances last season were taken by players aged 25 or younger. After a brilliant first half, Wood scuffled down the stretch. Consistency from the spindly slugger is key. So is developing the other kids on the roster, players like Dylan Crews, Brady House, CJ Abrams and Daylen Lile, into needle-moving pieces.

The pitching staff presents an even more formidable task. Only the Rockies, in their launching pad of a ballpark in the sky, had a higher ERA last season. Improvement on that front will largely be the responsibility of new pitching coach Simon Mathews, formerly an assistant with the Cincinnati Reds. Mathews, whose hiring was first reported by Yahoo Sports, is even younger than his skipper, having turned 30 just two months ago.

Blue Jays could be MLBs biggest offseason wild card with a potential run at Kyle Tucker

His hiring was yet another data point that Toboni and Co. plan to chart a new path. That dynamic was further reinforced at Butera’s news conference Monday. For better or worse, this era of Nats baseball will not unfurl with a strategy of half-measures. Over the last half decade, the Nationals have been an emblem of regressive, archaic baseball thinking. Unwilling and unable to adapt, the game passed them by, leaving them playing catch-up.

The shift under Toboni will be significant, comprehensive and immediate. Big swings will be taken. Character will be prioritized over experience. They will dream big. It is risky and refreshing. Butera may well be too young, too green for such a big job. He might be great at the gig and the players fall short anyway. Perhaps he’ll manage here for decades and oversee the glory years of D.C. baseball. Time will tell. But on Monday afternoon, he certainly looked the part and said all the right things in the right way.

For Nats fans, it is, at the very least, a plan to believe in.