Shockwaves in Detroit: Analyst Brands Dan Campbell’s Eagles Game Performance ‘Atrocious’—What Went Wrong?

So here’s the real kicker: How many times can a head coach’s bravado actually backfire before it stops being “confident” and starts feeling downright reckless? Dan Campbell’s Detroit Lions marched into Week 11 with guns blazing, throwing caution to the wind against the Eagles—but instead of clinching a win, they ended up with criticism flying as fast as their aggressive play calls. Now, I get it—going for it on fourth down has become almost fashionable in today’s NFL; but Campbell pushing all his chips in on every hand? That’s a gamble not even Vegas would endorse. Watching the Lions struggle to move the ball against Philly’s ironclad defense, yet persistently daring fate with high-risk calls, felt less like strategic genius and more like a recipe for disaster. And isn’t it curious how sometimes the smartest play is simply to take the points and shake hands? This isn’t just a one-off blunder; it’s a pattern unveiling itself under Campbell’s watch—and honestly, it has me wondering if that fiery spirit is lighting the way or just starting unnecessary fires.

SANTA CLARA, CALIFORNIA - JANUARY 28: Head coach Dan Campbell of the Detroit Lions looks on prior to a game against the San Francisco 49ers in the NFC Championship Game at Levi's Stadium on January 28, 2024 in Santa Clara, California. — (Photo by Ezra Shaw/Getty Images)

The Detroit Lions were too aggressive for their own good in Week 11. Unfortunately, that wasn’t a fluke.

Head coach Dan Campbell has the utmost confidence in his offense. While that makes sense to a degree, he’s also too aggressive at times.

Analyst John Middlekauff said Campbell was “atrocious” in the loss to the Philadelphia Eagles.

“I thought Dan Campbell was atrocious tonight. I don’t think there’s any way around it. Like, he was reckless. Going for it on fourth down is something that is supported in football now, and most of us are behind it. But there’s also a line of like, this is a defensive game and sometimes field position in a game that is 13-6, you don’t always need to go for it on fourth down. You’re not playing the Eagles of last year. Rough night for Dan Campbell,” Middlekauff said.

Dan Campbell & Jared Goff were ATROCIOUS against the Eagles. @JohnMiddlekauff reacts to the Lions loss on SNF & calls out their head coach for being reckless with the play calling in a defensive battle against the Eagles. pic.twitter.com/hiOjrXcYSo

— 3 & OUT with John Middlekauff (@3andout_pod) November 17, 2025

The Lions had trouble moving the ball against the Eagles’ stout front seven. Yet, Campbell continued to challenge them in crucial situations, going empty-handed in a game that was never out of reach.

This isn’t the first time this has happened to the Lions under Campbell. Judging by his character and approach to the game, it won’t be the last, either.

There’s a reason teams don’t always go for it on fourth down. Sometimes, it’s OK to just take the points instead of swinging for the fences at every opportunity.

Detroit lost what could be a preview of the NFC Championship Game. Philadelphia head coach Nick Sirianni and defensive coordinator Vic Fangio coached circles around Campbell this time.

The Lions clearly have the talent to go toe-to-toe with anybody. That doesn’t mean they should approach every game as if they were playing “Madden” at home with their friends.

The post Analyst Says Dan Campbell Was ‘Atrocious’ Against Eagles appeared first on The Cold Wire.