Unveiling MLB’s Speed Demons: The Wild-Card Era’s Lightning-Fast Games You Won’t Believe!

The Detroit media called it “the 28-out perfect game,” but Armando Galarraga fell shy of the record book when after the righty recorded 26 straight outs, umpire Jim Joyce ruled Cleveland’s Jason Donald – the 27th batter – safe with an infield single. Instant replay showed the call was incorrect, but it stood because MLB didn’t implement full video review until 2014. Galarraga (67 strikes out of 88 pitches, or 76.1%) retired the next batter for a one-hitter, then received an apology from Joyce after the game.       
The post MLB’s Fastest Games During the Wild-Card Era appeared first on Opta Analyst.

Baseball’s gotten a bad rap over the years for dragging on forever – you know, those endless innings that tested even the most diehard fans’ patience. But, guess what? MLB shook things up in 2023, speeding up the game and putting an end to those marathon sessions. Still, if you think the fastest games only started with the pitch timer, you’d be surprised. Most of the quickest wild-card era matchups actually happened before the rule changes, showcasing how sharp pitching and timely hitting kept the pace lively long before clocks were ticking down. So, do baseball games really have to feel like a Sunday stroll, or can lightning-fast moments still shine through? Let’s dive into the wild-card era’s speediest duels — and maybe even uncover the legendary “perfect game that wasn’t.” LEARN MORE.

Like this story on MLB’s fastest games? Check out our MLB coverage, and follow us on X and Instagram for more! 

The much-embraced pitch timer arrived in the 30th anniversary season of Major League Baseball’s wild-card era (note the postseason in the inaugural 1994 campaign wound up being canceled by a work stoppage).

The Braves trailed 2-1 on two unearned runs when Fred McGriff and Jermaine Dye hit solo home runs in the top of the seventh of this National League Division Series contest. Greg Maddux, who was an ERA wonder while collecting four consecutive NL Cy Young Awards from 1992-95, worked seven strong innings and combined with two relievers to retire the final 16 Dodgers’ batters.

As the list indicates, the fastest MLB games often occur when the home team is winning and the bottom of the ninth isn’t necessary. In the fastest game, White Sox left-hander Mark Buehrle outdueled Ryan Franklin as both threw complete games and allowed a combined eight hits and walks, throwing strikes on 134 of 197 pitches (68.0%). Paul Konerko fueled the White Sox offense with a pair of solo home runs.

MLB’s Fastest Games in Wild-Card Era (Regular Season)

While the implementation of the pitch timer as a major change in the 2023 season led to quicker baseball games, shutouts, complete games and batters getting into the box in a timely fashion (now they do under the rule change) have always kept the pace of play moving along.

1. 1:39 – At Chicago White Sox 2, Seattle Mariners 1 (April 16, 2005)

No pitch clock needed here in the final postseason before the rule change: Shane Bieber worked 7.2 innings and Emmanuel Clase had a four-out save. Jose Siri gave the Rays a 1-0 lead with a home run in the top of the sixth, but the Guardian’ Jose Ramirez answered with a two-run shot off Shane McClanahan in the bottom of the inning.

2. 1:41 – At Detroit Tigers 3, Kansas City Royals 0 (July 24, 2002)

The Braves’ many outstanding pitching staffs during the 1990s reflect across the fastest postseason game times of the wild-card era, including the three quickest and five of the top 12 overall.

T-3. 1:44 – At Detroit Tigers 3, Cleveland 0 (June 2, 2010)

Nonetheless, in looking back across the wild-card era, you didn’t want to be stuck in traffic outside a stadium on the days of the fastest games (nine or more innings). These box scores were clean. Notable on the list is Armando Galarraga’s perfect game that wasn’t in 2010.

T-3. 1:44 – At Toronto Blue Jays 3, Kansas City Royals 1 (May 10, 2005)

Perhaps you were resting up after watching too many four-hour-plus marathon games.

MLB’s Fastest Games in Wild-Card Era (Postseason)

Baseball once had a reputation for being too long, but it’s no longer the case with MLB speeding up the action beginning in 2023. As part of our MLB coverage, we look at the fastest games of the wild-card era, and most of the games occurred before the newer rules.

1. 2:08 – Atlanta Braves 3, at Los Angeles Dodgers 2 (NLDS Game 2; Oct. 3, 1996)

Baseball’s five-fastest regular-season games of the wild-card era – at least nine-inning games –have occurred in the American League, with the Detroit Tigers involved three times. The Toronto Blue Jays are involved in three of the six fastest games, including an interleague matchup against the Atlanta Braves.

2. 2:09 – At San Diego Padres 4, Atlanta Braves 0 (NL Wild Card Game 1; Oct. 1, 2024)

3. 2:13 – At Atlanta Braves 5, Houston Astros 1 (NLDS Game 2; Oct. 6, 1999)

No Royals base runner reached scoring position as Tigers righty Jose Lima allowed two hits across seven innings and combined with two relievers on the shutout. Randall Simon’s second-inning home run off the right-field foul pole put the Tigers ahead to stay.

4. 2:15 – At Atlanta Braves 2, Houston Astros 1 (NLDS Game 1; Sept. 30, 1997)

The Astros outhit the Braves 7-2, but Maddux limited them to one run – an RBI single by losing pitcher Darryl Kile – while throwing 114 pitches – the most of his 30 postseason games. Ryan Klesko’s solo homer to lead off the bottom of the second staked the Braves to a 2-0 lead.  

5. 2:17 – At Cleveland Guardians 2, Tampa Bay Rays 1 (AL Wild-Card Game 1; Oct. 7, 2022)

If you blinked, maybe you missed the fastest games in recent MLB history.

Roy Halladay scattered eight hits in a complete-game win over the Royals, whose manager, Tony Pena, resigned later that night due to their 8-25 record. Shea Hillenbrand’s two-run home run in the bottom of the third broke a 1-1 tie, and it ended the scoring.  
Kevin Millwood allowed only a solo home run with zero walks while facing only 29 batters in a complete-game win. Brian Jordan plated his second RBI as the Braves put the game away with three runs in the seventh.