Cleveland's Calculated Gamble: Did the Browns Deal Away Their Franchise Cornerstone?

Ready for a wild ride in the NFL Draft narrative? This year’s meeting of picks and drafting chaos wasn’t just about new helmets outshining on the turf…it was a seismic shift in team economics, with the Cleveland Browns at the epicenter of a trade that had everyone talking 🤼.

Get this—the Cleveland Browns did something utterly astounding in their trade with the Jacksonville Jaguars on night one of the draft, trading away Travis Hunter, a two-way college phenom, in swap of gaining what many are calling a “haul” of assets [[link barred]]. But let’s pause for a sec… Hunter, likened to the unique force on the baseball diamond, Shohei Ohtani, was positioned to be a can’t-miss NFL talent with the ability to disrupt game plans on both offense and defense.

The Browns, quite the franchise in the spotlight right now, could’ve arguably, on the surface, used a bit of Hunter’s charisma and star pull, particularly on the heels of their less-than-stellar quarterback decisions culminating in the Deshaun Watson trade⚖️. Instead, they’ve made a move that’s all about strategic planning, ensuring they have ample draft picks to look for potential gems in 2025 and a pivotal first-round pick in 2026, aka the quarterback year.

According to Cleveland’s GM, this is all about setting up for a grand, quarterback-sponsored resurgence—think Arch Manning, Nico Iamaleava, Drew Allar, or LaNorris Sellers. With deep breaths from sitting room analysts to spontaneous jumping at the bar, this move will echo through time, shaping the franchise’s journey in the coming year and beyond.

Cleveland went straight for the long game in a shocking draft-night trade, making us wonder—was it the masterful stroke of genius or a gamble to costly to fathom? One thing’s clear—this is a trade Cleveland wont be forgetting.

LEARN MORE.

By the numbers, the Cleveland Browns made off with a haul in their shocking early-draft-night trade with the Jacksonville Jaguars. By the vibes, though, the Browns might have traded away the future of the NFL.

Cleveland and Jacksonville provided the draft night’s first major thrill with the announcement of the Round 1 trade Thursday night at the NFL Draft, which gave the Jags the opportunity to draft two-way college whirlwind Travis Hunter. It’s impossible to predict how Hunter will play out, but it’s safe to say that he’ll be must-watch, given that he’ll get significant reps on both sides of the ball. Heck, Cleveland’s own general manager compared Hunter to the Los Angeles Dodgers’ Shohei Ohtani.

Advertisement

Yes, Shohei Ohtani, the player who basically singlehandedly conquered baseball, thanks to his elite skills at the plate and on the mound. That’s who Cleveland opted against taking.

Granted, there are significant differences between a two-way baseball player and a two-way football player, starting with the fact that it’s debatable whether Hunter can play more than a handful of plays on both sides of the ball. But it’s not hard to envision Hunter being the most visible non-quarterback in the league, the kind of player who can disrupt the opposition no matter where he lines up, and raise the profile of his whole team at the same time. Cleveland, still reeling from a string of bad choices that culminated in the Deshaun Watson trade, sure could have used some of that goodwill and star power.

So what exactly did the Browns get in return for giving up possibly the most exciting player in the game? A flat-out haul. Cleveland traded away the pick that became Hunter, along with a fourth-round pick (No. 104) and a sixth-round pick (No. 200), and in return received the No. 5 pick (which they turned into Michigan DT Mason Graham), a second-round pick (No. 36), a fourth-round pick (No. 126) and — most notably — a 2026 first-round pick.

Advertisement

In other words, Cleveland moved up nearly 70 spots above its fourth-round pick, and nearly 75 spots from its sixth-round pick, and got an extra 2026 first-rounder. The move here for Cleveland is clear:

First, a restocking of the franchise’s draft capital following the pantry-clearing from the 2022 Watson trade.

Second, and more importantly for Cleveland’s purposes, this gives the Browns multiple bites at the quarterback apple, both in 2025 and 2026.

The 2026 quarterback draft class is forecast at much stronger than this year’s crop, with Texas’ Arch Manning, UCLA’s Nico Iamaleava, Penn State’s Drew Allar and South Carolina’s LaNorris Sellers leading the way. Cleveland is in desperate — some would say franchise-long — need of a quarterback, and one of those players could provide the boost the Browns need, courtesy of Jacksonville.

Advertisement

The Browns could have used Hunter, both as an on-field spark plug and an off-field PR boost for a beleaguered franchise. Cleveland opted to take another route, figuring that a winning organization trumps a single marquee player … even a player who’s two stars in one.

One way or another, this is a trade Cleveland will remember for many years to come.