Could This Unconventional Coaching Choice Revolutionize the Giants’ Future?

So, the New York Giants finally decided to pull the plug on Brian Daboll’s tenure — long overdue, don’t you think? Yet, here’s the kicker: Joe Schoen sticks around, tasked with hunting down the next head honcho. Now, imagine this curveball former NFLer Jason McCourty threw into the mix — what if Mike Tomlin, the Steelers’ stalwart, suddenly found himself packing up his playbook for East Rutherford? Sure, Tomlin’s not your conventional offensive guru to nurture a young QB like Jaxson Dart, but boy, could he bring the swagger and stability this franchise desperately needs. Is it a fantasy or a brilliant masterstroke waiting in the wings? Either way, one thing’s for sure — the Giants are poised at a crossroads, and the coaching carousel just got a whole lot more interesting.

(Photo by Sarah Stier/Getty Images)

The New York Giants finally fired head coach Brian Daboll, and while the front office may have more to do with the team’s failures than he did, it seemed overdue.

Yet, the Giants will keep general manager Joe Schoen. More than that, he’s reportedly going to lead the search for Daboll’s replacement.

With that in mind, former NFL player Jason McCourty proposed an interesting coaching option for the Giants.

“I’ve heard so many names get thrown out. One name I heard today, was someone mentioned Mike Tomlin. What if he and the Pittsburgh Steelers mutually part ways? What could he possibly do, not only for Jaxson Dart, but for that organization that’s been in turmoil for the last several years? He would instantly bring stability to the entire organization and be able to show the people there what it’s supposed to look like to build a winning franchise. That’s a very interesting name that goes out there,” McCourty said.

One interesting name for the Giants HC spot: Mike Tomlin.

Super Bowl LIII Champ Jason McCourty on why the pairing could work:@JasonMcCourty | @heykayadams pic.twitter.com/oK9gEaP2ET

— Up & Adams (@UpAndAdamsShow) November 11, 2025

For years, rumors have circulated that Tomlin is ready to move on from the Steelers. He would probably become one of the most sought-after head coaches in the league if that were to happen.

Of course, Tomlin isn’t known for offensive expertise, so he may not be the right coach to develop a young quarterback like Dart. That being said, he could certainly help restore a winning culture in New York.

There haven’t been any recent reports that Tomlin is on the hot seat or is actually thinking about leaving Pittsburgh. Yet, with quarterback Aaron Rodgers possibly retiring at the end of the season, and the Steelers likely entering a rebuilding phase, Tomlin may want to take on another challenge elsewhere.

The post Former Player Proposes Interesting Coaching Option For Giants appeared first on The Cold Wire.