Edgerrin James Drops a Shocking NFL MVP Prediction That No One Saw Coming

Ever wonder if a running back could actually snag the NFL MVP crown in a quarterback-obsessed era? Well, Jonathan Taylor’s 2025 campaign might just be shaking up that long-standing narrative. Watching those Indianapolis Colts helmets resting quietly on the sidelines at Lucas Oil Stadium, you wouldn’t initially guess the seismic shift brewing beneath — but JT has become the unstoppable engine behind Indy’s playoff ambitions. It’s rare these days to see a non-QB seriously stir MVP chatter, yet here we are, with former Colts legend Edgerrin James boldly putting his chips on Taylor. With touchdowns piling up and yards creeping toward the elusive 2,000 mark, Taylor’s relentless grind forces us to ask: Can sheer excellence and volume break through the positional bias that’s held the MVP trophy hostage for so long? Let’s dive into this unfolding story that could rewrite NFL lore, one powerful run at a time…

Indianapolis Colts helmets rest on the sidelines during the pregame warmup before the AFC Wild Card game against the Cincinnati Bengals at Lucas Oil Stadium on January 4, 2015 in Indianapolis, Indiana. — (Photo by Andy Lyons/Getty Images)

Jonathan Taylor has emerged as the driving force behind the Indianapolis Colts‘ postseason push. While Daniel Jones has performed above expectations at quarterback, Taylor’s impact transcends typical statistical measures.

His 2025 season ranks among the finest of his career, positioning him as a legitimate factor in the MVP conversation despite historical bias favoring signal-callers. The notion of a running back winning MVP faces considerable headwinds in modern football.

Quarterbacks have dominated the award for over a decade, with Adrian Peterson being the last non-QB winner in 2012. Still, former Colts star Edgerrin James believes this season presents a genuine opportunity to break that pattern.

“Who’s got the edge in this MVP race? You already know. My guy, JT. When I watch him, I see pro work, vision, patience, and then burst. If I was talking about the MVP, there’s only one choice: JT—Jonathan Taylor,” James said during a recent CBS segment.

"If I was talking about the MVP… there's only one choice."

Edgerrin James loves what he's seeing from Jonathan Taylor this season

One legendary @Colts RB respecting another pic.twitter.com/hg1X3risxi

— NFL on CBS (@NFLonCBS) November 23, 2025

Taylor currently has 17 touchdowns and is tracking toward eclipsing his previous career high of 20. He has recorded five games with three scores and is on pace to reach the 2,000-yard mark, an exclusive achievement reached by only a select group of running backs throughout NFL history.

His production has been relentless and consistent week after week. However, the MVP race remains crowded with legitimate contenders.

Matthew Stafford, Drake Maye, Josh Allen, and Patrick Mahomes all command consideration as the season winds toward its conclusion. The competition will likely intensify as teams make their final pushes down the stretch.

Taylor’s case for MVP consideration rests on exceptional efficiency and volume across the season. Whether voters will overlook positional bias and award a running back the honor remains uncertain. What’s clear is that Taylor has done everything within his control to make himself impossible to ignore in discussions about the league’s best player.

The post Edgerrin James Reveals His NFL MVP Pick This Season appeared first on The Cold Wire.