Juan Soto’s Unexpected Comeback to Hustle Critics Sparks Heated Debate After Green Monster Blast

You can’t imagine the last thing Juan Soto wanted after Sunday’s Mets-Yankees game was to be grilled by the New York press about hustle, or rather the glaring lack of it. Picture this: the game knotted up at 2-2 in the eighth inning, the stadium buzzing…and then Soto, the Mets’ big bat, slows up on what should have been a routine ground-ball single, ultimately ending in an out. Ouch. To make matters worse? It happened in an 8-2 drubbing at the hands of their fiercest rivals, the Yankees.

But wait, the saga didn’t stop there. Fast forward to Monday night, the Mets trailing the Red Sox 3-1 in Fenway Park, Soto laces a deep shot to left field against Justin Wilson. Initially thinking it was a homer, he leisurely jogged the bases only to realize the Green Monster had other plans — turning potential fireworks into a mere single. By the time he figured it out, extra bases were gone with the wind. Sure, Soto redeemed himself a bit by swiping second base, but Boston held on for a clutch victory nonetheless.

When pressed postgame about his “slow getting out of the box,” Soto shrugged it off, insisting he’s been putting in the effort. Mets manager Carlos Mendoza didn’t jump down his star player’s throat either, but made it clear there’d be a conversation — especially considering the gargantuan 15-year, $765 million contract Soto inked last December, the biggest in sports history. The expectation for hustle? Sky-high.

It’s early only 47 games into his Mets tenure, and yeah, Soto’s numbers—.246/.379/.443 before Monday’s game—haven’t quite lived up to that superstar shine yet. But if anyone’s seen Juan Soto’s track record, patience is the name of the game. The Mets are sitting pretty at 29-19, and Soto will find his groove. That said, plays like these certainly aren’t how you win over the famously discerning Mets faithful.

LEARN MORE

These are not the questions Juan Soto wants to face from New York media.

On Sunday, the New York Mets slugger took heat for not sprinting on a potential ground-ball single that instead resulted in an out. Even worse — it came in an 8-2 loss to the New York Yankees.

Advertisement

The game was tied at 2-2 in the eighth inning when Soto recorded the first out of the top of the inning.

“Everything about it in slow-motion,” said ESPN’s Karl Ravech on the play-by-play call.

On Monday, Soto took even more heat for a high-profile lack of hustle. This time on the road against the Boston Red Sox.

With the Mets trailing, 3-1 in the top of sixth inning, Soto sent a blast deep to left field off of Red Sox reliever Justin Wilson. Soto thought he had a home run. But the Green Monster caught it and sent the ball bouncing back into the field of play.

The deep fly ball resulted in a single.

Another broadcast edit focuses on Soto the whole time. He clearly believed that he had a home run secured. He admired the ball out of the box and broke into a trot before realizing that no, the ball was not leaving Fenway Park.

Advertisement

By then, it was too late. Soto started to round first before turning back for a single that could have certainly gone for extra bases.

Soto did his best to make up for it. He eventually stole second base. But the Red Sox held on for a 3-1 win.

After the game, Soto was asked by a reporter if he needs to be aware being “slow getting out of the box.” Soto doesn’t think there’s an issue.

“No,” Soto responded. “I think I’ve been hustling pretty hard. If you see it today, you could tell.”

Mets manager Carlos Mendoza was also asked about Soto’s hustle — or lack thereof. He declined to lay into his superstar outfielder who signed with the Mets in December to a 15-year, $765 million contract that’s the richest known deal in the history of sports.

Advertisement

Mendoza told reporters “we’ll discuss that.”

“We’ll talk to him about it,” Mendoza said. “Tonight, obviously, someone gets a hold of one and knows when he gets it, he’s Juan, you know. He thought he had it. With the wind and all that.

“And in this ballpark or anywhere, but in particular this one with that wall right there, you’ve got to get out of the box. We’ll discuss that.”

Soto’s 47 games into his Mets tenure. He’s not off to a great start when compared to his lofty standards. Prior to Monday, Soto had a slash line of .246/.379/.443, numbers all well below his career line of .283/.419/.528.

Advertisement

He went 1 for 4 against the Red Sox with no counting stats outside of his stolen base and is now up to eight home runs and 20 RBI for the season. It’s not the production the Mets were counting on.

The long run will obviously tell the story, and Soto’s track record all but ensures that he’ll deliver over the long run. And the Mets are off to a strong start at 29-19, a half-game behind the first-place Phillies in the NL East.

Soto will be fine. But his efforts against the Red Sox and Yankees are not the best way to endear himself to his new legion of Mets fans.