Premier League’s Summer Transfer Gambles: Who Will Rise and Who Will Regret It?

Diving into the whirlwind of football transfers, it’s clear one thing: every deal is a roll of the dice. Seriously, how often do we see dazzling signings that stir the airwaves, only to fizzle out unexpectedly? And then there are those dark horses, flying under the radar, suddenly dominating the pitch and rewriting the headlines. That unpredictability—it’s part of what makes football both thrilling and nerve-wracking. The stakes? Sky-high. What might look like a masterstroke could just as easily flop, leaving fans and pundits scratching their heads. Now, sure, some transfers are gambles on a whole other level—those are the ones that keep us on the edge of our seats, debating if they’ll soar or sink. So, let’s unpack five headline-making moves this season that sit right smack in that uncertain middle ground. Ready to explore who might light up the Premier League and who might leave us wondering?

LEARN MORE

Every transfer, to a degree, is a gamble. There really is very little way of telling whether an arrival is going to thrive or flop.

Over the years, there have been plenty of examples of both. Some big-name players have graced the Premier League to much fanfare and excitement – not to mention hefty price tags – only to then disappoint once they step out onto the pitch, while some have arrived very much under the radar but then gone on to become superstars in their own right.

Risk is the name of the game here, really. It essentially boils down to a decision that has the potential to pay off in spectacular fashion or quickly nosedive into embarrassment.

Perhaps it is fair to say that some signing are more risky than others. Here are five that really could go either way.

Gianluigi Donnarumma – PSG to Manchester City

Were it not for Alexander Isak’s long-awaited move to Liverpool, this may well have been the headline signing on deadline day.

A Champions League-winning keeper joining another powerhouse of European football, on paper at least, might seem like a very normal bit of business. However, the towering Italian nevertheless feels like an odd fit for a Pep Guardiola ethos that relies so heavily on the keeper being slick, given that Donnarumma has proven on several occasions that he is not always that comfortable with his feet.

That said, there are few keepers in world football with the shot-stopping capability of the 26-year-old. The £26m fee may also prove to be a steal, too. Only time will tell.

Nick Woltemade – Stuttgart to Newcastle United

Even for a player who carries the nickname “the two-metre Messi”, a £70m transfer fee for a 23-year-old with no Champions League experience and just two senior international caps might be considered risky.

However, Nick Woltemade’s goal return remains impressive. He bagged 17 goals in all competitions last season as Stuttgart lifted the DfB Pokal, their first major trophy in close to two decades, and was top scorer in the European U21 Championship with six-goals as Germany reached the final, where they lost to England.

Many will inevitably measure him against the man he has been brought in to replace at Newcastle, so there is already a lot of pressure on this highly-regarded young striker’s shoulders.

Benjamin Sesko – RB Leipzig to Manchester United

Should the £73.3m rated Slovenian hit the ground running at Manchester United, it may have a direct impact on the future of manager Ruben Amorim.

Amorim is facing another tough spell in the hot seat at Old Trafford after an underwhelming start to the campaign that has included an EFL Cup defeat at the hands of League Two Grimsby Town.

So, in a word, Benjamin Sesko’s arrival is a gamble. He certainly has pedigree. Twenty-seven goals in 64 Bundesliga games – a rate of better than one goal every three games – can attest to that. But the 22-year-old is by no means the finished article and may take some time to adjust.

By that point, it could already be too late for the man who brought him to the club.

Viktor Gyokeres – Sporting Lisbon to Arsenal

Unlike the others on this list, the Gunners’ new £64m signing already boasts experience playing in England. Viktor Gyokeres penned a deal with Brighton in 2018 but spent most of his time there out on loan, before making a move to Coventry permanent in 2021.

Again, his stats speak for themselves, having scored a remarkable 97 goals in 102 matches for Portuguese powerhouses Sporting, including a hat-trick against Manchester City in the Champions League last season.

But one of Mikel Arteta’s marquee summer acquisitions will have a job trying to replicate that kind of return in England’s top-flight. And given criticism in recent season of their inability to attract an out-and-out goalscorer, it is likely that Gyokeres’ goals – or lack thereof – will have a direct correlation with the seriousness of the north Londoners’ title hopes.

Florian Wirtz – Bayer Leverkusen to Liverpool

One could reasonably argue that any signing over £100m is a huge gamble. But perhaps even more so for a player without any previous Premier League experience.

That is the case for Liverpool’s Florian Wirtz, who, at £116m, held the title of Liverpool’s most expensive ever player for all of, erm, 10 weeks.

The arrival of Isak for £125m may well take some of the heat off Wirtz to instantly live up to that hefty price tag, but the German will still be looked to as one of Arne Slot’s most creative sparks.

While his first few league games have not yet yielded any goals or assists, Wirtz has shown glimpses of his talents and will be a force to be reckoned with if he is able to reach his undoubted potential.