Shocking Twist: Betting Odds Outshine Expert Predictions in 2025 NFL Draft

Ladies and gentlemen, sports enthusiasts and betting buffs, I’ve got a mind-bender for you. What if I told you that the pundits, the so-called draft gurus, who pontificate with all the knowledge of a sage, are less effective at predicting NFL draft picks than the cold, hard, cash driven betting odds? Yep, you read that right – the sportsbooks outshined the experts when it came to the 2025 NFL Draft‘s top-10 picks. Makes you wonder, doesn’t it? Were these insiders just guessing, or was their hubris their downfall? Meanwhile, the sportsbooks, with their money on the line, had no room for error.

I swear I couldn’t believe it either, but the numbers don’t lie. From the Jaguars’ surprise trade for the No. 2 pick, which nobody saw coming, to selecting Colorado’s versatile WR/CB Travis Hunter, the favorite didn’t just pick up points, but they did so with an odd sense of foresight. It’s almost like they knew what they were doing.

As much as I revel in the shock value of drafts, even I must admit, in a world saturated with information, the betting markets truly showcased a remarkable prescience. It wasn’t just a fluke either; the consensus was so strong that if you had bet blindly on the favorites for the first round’s top-10 picks, you would’ve pocketed $450 in profit, according to the odds. It’s like the sportsbooks were reading the room better than the insiders could dream of.

Would you have hitched your wagon to the betting odds instead of the cacophony of ‘expert’ opinions? It’s a tantalizing thought, a little like wondering if you could’ve bet on the story of the Red Sea parting. But hey, don’t sweat it if you didn’t, because maybe next year, we’ll all be wiser, tuning out the noise and tuning into the real beasts in the prediction game: Vegas.

DISCLAIMER: I don’t condone reckless gambling. Please bet responsibly, but above all have fun! LEARN MORE.

Don’t listen to the insiders next year. Instead, pay attention to the betting odds because the sportsbooks did a better job predicting the 2025 NFL Draft‘s top-10 picks than people who do mock drafts professionally. The favorites to be taken in the first seven picks Thursday all cashed. 

Granted, how they got there was a little wonky. For instance, you couldn’t specifically bet that the Jacksonville Jaguars would trade their fifth pick and future draft capital to the Cleveland Browns for the second pick. Yet, Jacksonville traded up to select Colorado Buffaloes WR/CB Travis Hunter at No. 2, who was a hefty -900 favorite to go second. 

But, Cleveland did right by the market and took Michigan Wolverines DT Mason Graham fifth, and he was a -115 favorite to get drafted in that spot. Before Graham, the New York Giants picked Penn State Nittany Lions pass rusher Abdul Carter third (-650), and the New England Patriots grabbed LSU Tigers OT Will Campbell at No. 4 (-450). 

Despite getting late action to be picked fifth overall, which I fell for, Boise State Broncos RB Ashton Jeanty went to the Las Vegas Raiders at No. 6 (-125), as the sportsbooks projected earlier this week. The only plus-money payout among the top-seven picks won when the New York Jets drafted Missouri Tigers OT Armand Membou (+150) seventh. 

Then, the betting favorites to go 8-10 struck out. The Carolina Panthers opted for Arizona Wildcats WR Tetairoa McMillan with the eighth pick rather than Georgia Bulldogs LB Jalon Walker, who had the best odds of going there (+150). Texas Longhorns OT Kelvin Banks Jr. went to the New Orleans Saints at No. 9, not the favorite Colorado QB Shedeur Sanders (+215). 

The biggest surprise of the first round was the Chicago Bears passing on Penn State TE Tyler Warren (+350) to draft Michigan TE Colston Loveland 10th. Warren closed as a -450 favorite to be the first tight end selected in the 2025 NFL Draft. I didn’t see anyone mock Loveland ahead of Warren among the 20 mock drafts I read before Thursday. 

Look, as someone who bets sports daily, I’ve trusted sportsbook odds for games, futures, player awards, etc. more than the so-called “experts” for years. That said, the movement of NFL draft odds is usually due to people betting stuff (aka “price speculation”) following an insider’s report or a popular analyst’s mock draft. But, this is a great reminder that “money talks and bullsh*t walks”. 

Finally, if you blindly bet to win $100 on the favorites for the first round’s top-10 picks, you would’ve profited $450 from the 2025 NFL Draft Thursday. Albeit, it would’ve taken two “bridge jumper bets” on Miami Hurricanes QB Cam Ward (-20000) and Hunter. However, a $450 gain over two hours sounds like a good return on investment to me. 

_____________________________

Follow me on X (or Twitter, whatever) @Geoffery-Clark, and check out my OutKick Bets Podcast for more betting content and random rants.