Why the ‘Madden’ Movie Fails Spectacularly Despite High Hopes—A Shocking Breakdown
A technique the movie goes back to again, and again, and again is John Madden drawing up plays on the screen, as if he’s performing a telestrator routine just for the viewer. None of these work. They’re either overly simplistic for football fans, or confusing to non-football fans. They offer nothing outside of allowing Nicolas Cage to chew scenery and riff, never being good at either.
Madden is not a football movie, though the sport dominates so much of the narrative. It’s also not really a character study of John Madden himself. It’s not a drama, nor is it a comedy — it just … exists. There is an astonishing amount of whiplash taking place throughout the movie, in which one second John will be having a dramatic scene with his wife Virginia over failing his family in service of Al Davis and the Raiders, then the next will be a moment of comedy between Madden and his fictional neighbor Vince, who is played by Shane Gillis, who does absolutely nothing to be anything but Shane Gillis.The artistic license of this moment is critical because it’s not a side note of the story, but one of the primary conceits of the film. Getting these details wrong is astonishing, and calls into doubt most of the events shown. When Hawkins is rejected in 1977, Madden suggests he “ask Joe Montana” to be the namesake for the game. Montana did not take his first snap in the NFL until 1979.When a film lands with all the subtlety of a late hit on fourth and long, you know you’re in for something… unique. That’s exactly the vibe I got diving into Madden, a flick that popped onto Amazon Prime this week, and honestly, it left me scratching my head more than once. It tries to juggle football, biography, comedy, and drama — but somehow ends up dropping every ball. Centered on John Madden’s legendary run with the Oakland Raiders and the birth of the Madden NFL video game series, this movie skims over historic moments with the urgency of a quarterback avoiding a sack — and too often, it just stumbles. What’s particularly galling is when a story this ripe for greatness instead feels like a paycheck parade, complete with baffling inaccuracies and performances that clash like chalk and cheese. If you’re chasing a sharp sports narrative or a real character study, this isn’t it. But I must admit, there’s a strange, almost hypnotic allure in watching Nicolas Cage fumble through the role of Madden himself. Curious? LEARN MORE
Considering the significant setup this moment is given, it’s almost alarming how quickly the movie then skips through the AFC Championship game against Terry Bradshaw and the Steelers, before giving approximately 90 seconds of screen time to Madden’s victory in Super Bowl XI over the Vikings. It’s a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it moment, that moves from the pre-game, to the celebration — with almost no football in between.
AdvertisementThe movie opens on the tail end of John Madden’s run as head coach of the Oakland Raiders in 1977 at a time when pressure was on to win a Super Bowl after flaming out in the playoffs in four consecutive seasons. It’s established quickly that Madden is a brilliant coach, but viewed as incapable of winning the big one.AdvertisementWe’re left with a hollow, vacuous movie that seemingly exists only as a cash grab. There is no other explanation for how a director of David O. Russell’s caliber (Silver Linings Playbook, The Fighter, American Hustle) turned in what feels like a rushed, lackluster, mediocre film devoid of any redeeming elements. If you want to waste two hours of your time just to laugh at Nicolas Cage trying to be John Madden, go for it — but there is nothing else about this movie that makes it worth your time.



Post Comment